Facebook Engages in Housing Discrimination With Its Ad Practices, U.S. Says – The New York Times
The housing agency’s suit underscores how effective Facebook’s ad-targeting tools are, and how they could perpetuate discriminatory behavior if used by those who want to exclude people based on race, religion, gender or other criteria.
Facebook collects a vast amount of information about its users, and uses its technology to draw additional inferences about them. In its pitch to advertisers, the complaint says, the company notes that “most online advertising tools have limited targeting options” including “age, gender, interests and potentially a few others.” But, the pitch continues, “Facebook is different. People on Facebook share their true identities, interests, life events and more,” according to the complaint.
The complaint also accuses Facebook of going further than advertisers may ask in targeting users. The company’s “ad delivery system will not show the ad to a diverse audience if the system considers users with particular characteristics most likely to engage with the ad,” the complaint says, even if an advertiser wants the ad to be seen broadly by users.
“If the advertiser tries to avoid this problem by specifically targeting an unrepresented group, the ad delivery system will still not deliver the ad to those users, and it may not deliver the ad at all,” the complaint says.
The complaint does not name any advertisers who used Facebook’s targeted ad tools.
HUD’s lawsuit follows nearly three years of scrutiny of Facebook’s ad-targeting practices that started with a 2016 investigation by ProPublica, whose reporters showed that the company made it simple for marketers to exclude specific ethnic groups for advertising purposes.
Those who chose to could buy ads that excluded ethnic “affinity groups” like African-Americans, Asian-Americans and Hispanics in Facebook’s housing advertising category.
Within HUD, the lawsuit caps a long-running debate over whether and how to discipline Facebook.
In 2017, Mr. Carson’s aides scaled back an inquiry into the company’s housing-ad policies, going so far as to scrap a long-scheduled negotiating session with Facebook officials soon after the Trump administration took office.